Pour the Love is on — subscribe and save 20%. A free bag to give away in every subscription order. One-time orders: 15% off.

Savings bundle

Build Your Savings Bundle

Start with a single bag to try us — or build a bundle of three or more and save 15% with free shipping. Every bag supports the formation of future priests.

3 bags from $46.77 on your first delivery ($15.59/bag) · $49.71 one-time during Pour the Love · free shipping

  1. 1Pick your roasts
  2. 2Choose grind & delivery
  3. 3Subscribe & save 20% + a free bag in every order, or 15% off one-time during Pour the Love

Hope

Light roast · Agtron 80

Crisp Green Apple, Floral Jasmine & Honey Sweetness

$19.49 · 12 ozDetails →

0

Goodness

Light roast · Agtron 70

Apple, Bright Citrus, Sweet Floral & Cane Sugar

$19.49 · 12 ozDetails →

0

Charity

Medium roast · Agtron 60

Milk Chocolate, Bright Orange Zest & Toasted Almond

$19.49 · 12 ozDetails →

0

Beauty

Medium roast · Agtron 55

Milk Chocolate, Roasted Almond, Honey & Smooth Caramel

$19.49 · 12 ozDetails →

0
Decaf

Patience — Decaf

Medium roast · Agtron 50

Sweet Milk Chocolate, Soft Caramel & Graham Cracker

$19.49 · 12 ozDetails →

0

Faith

Dark roast · Agtron 45

Dark Brown Sugar, Caramelized Molasses & Heavy Buttery Body

$19.49 · 12 ozDetails →

0

Truth

Dark roast · Agtron 40

Dark Chocolate, Molasses & Toasted Cacao

$19.49 · 12 ozDetails →

0

Fortitude

Dark roast · Agtron 35

Dark Cocoa, Smoky Cedar & Syrupy Bittersweet Finish

$19.49 · 12 ozDetails →

0

Justice

French roast · Agtron 30–35

Toasted Marshmallow, Dark Molasses & Charred Oak Finish

$19.49 · 12 ozDetails →

0

The Agtron scale

Find the roast you actually like.

Agtron is a roast-color score read by a spectrophotometer — not an opinion. The higher the number, the lighter the roast: bright, fruity, acidic. The lower the number, the darker: bold, smoky, low acidity. Every Knights Coffee bag prints its score, so you can order the next one with confidence.

Hope80Goodness70Charity60Beauty55Patience50Faith45Truth40Fortitude35Justice30–35
Lighter roastDarker roast
  • Hope

    Light roast

    80

    Agtron

    Green apple · Jasmine · Honey

  • Truthly × Knights

    Goodness

    Light roast

    70

    Agtron

    Apple · Bright citrus · Sweet floral · Cane sugar

  • Charity

    Light-medium roast

    60

    Agtron

    Milk chocolate · Orange zest · Almond

  • Truthly × Knights

    Beauty

    Medium roast

    55

    Agtron

    Milk chocolate · Roasted almond · Honey · Smooth caramel

  • Patience

    Decaf · medium

    50

    Agtron

    Milk chocolate · Caramel · Graham cracker

  • Faith

    Dark roast

    45

    Agtron

    Brown sugar · Molasses · Buttery body

  • Truthly × Knights

    Truth

    Dark roast

    40

    Agtron

    Dark chocolate · Molasses · Toasted cacao

  • Fortitude

    Dark roast

    35

    Agtron

    Dark cocoa · Smoky cedar · Bittersweet

  • Justice

    French roast

    30–35

    Agtron

    Toasted marshmallow · Molasses · Oak

The Cup Score

84 points. Four points above the line that matters.

Every coffee in the world can be scored out of 100 by certified graders — aroma, flavor, acidity, body, balance, sweetness. 80 is the line. Score 80 or higher with zero primary defects and it's specialty coffee. Score under it and it's commodity — whatever the label says. Our coffees cup at 84.

The specialty line · 80Under 80, it isn't specialty. Period. Knights Coffee84Points · $19.49 a bag
Below 80 · Not specialty80–85 · Very good85–90 · Excellent90+ · Outstanding
$4–$10 a bag$15–$22 a bag$22–$35 a bag$35–$100+ a bag
60708090100

Where big-brand coffee lives: the whole gray stretch under 80. Commodity coffee is bought on price, not points — most of it is never cup-scored at all.

Why specialty costs more

What the extra points are paying for

  • Graded, not guessed

    Certified Q Graders cup every lot across ten attributes before it earns a score. Under 80 doesn't make the cut — literally. There's no marketing word for it because it isn't specialty.

  • Zero primary defects

    Specialty grade allows no moldy, sour, or insect-damaged beans in the grading sample. What's in the cup is the coffee itself — nothing has to be hidden or burned off.

  • Picked ripe, paid right

    Specialty lots are picked at peak ripeness and bought for quality at above-commodity prices — traceable to real farms and real farmers, then roasted in small batches and shipped fresh.

The big-brand reality

Why the cheap bag is cheap

  • Bought like corn

    Commodity coffee trades on an exchange by the ton, like corn or oil. The cheapest lot wins the contract. The score isn't part of the deal — it isn't even measured.

  • Defects by the handful

    Commodity grading permits defective beans in every lot — unripe, fermented, insect-damaged. Roast it dark enough and every coffee tastes the same: burnt. That's not a style. It's a cover-up.

  • Old before you buy it

    Roasted months ahead, warehoused, shipped, and shelved. By the time it brews, whatever flavor it once had is gone — what's left is bitter, flat, and stale.

Scores per the Specialty Coffee Association's 100-point cupping scale.
Specialty grade: 80+ points with zero primary defects. Bag prices are typical US retail ranges for a 12 oz bag in each band.