Pour the Love is on — subscribe and save 20%. A free bag to give away in every subscription order. One-time orders: 15% off.
Savings bundle
Build Your Savings Bundle
Start with a single bag to try us — or build a bundle of three or more and save 15% with free shipping. Every bag supports the formation of future priests.
3 bags from $46.77 on your first delivery ($15.59/bag) · $49.71 one-time during Pour the Love · free shipping
- 1Pick your roasts
- 2Choose grind & delivery
- 3Subscribe & save 20% + a free bag in every order, or 15% off one-time during Pour the Love
Medium roast · Agtron 55
Milk Chocolate, Roasted Almond, Honey & Smooth Caramel
$19.49 · 12 ozDetails →
Dark roast · Agtron 45
Dark Brown Sugar, Caramelized Molasses & Heavy Buttery Body
$19.49 · 12 ozDetails →
The Agtron scale
Find the roast you actually like.
Agtron is a roast-color score read by a spectrophotometer — not an opinion. The higher the number, the lighter the roast: bright, fruity, acidic. The lower the number, the darker: bold, smoky, low acidity. Every Knights Coffee bag prints its score, so you can order the next one with confidence.
Hope
Light roast
80
Agtron
Green apple · Jasmine · Honey
Truthly × Knights
Goodness
Light roast
70
Agtron
Apple · Bright citrus · Sweet floral · Cane sugar
Charity
Light-medium roast
60
Agtron
Milk chocolate · Orange zest · Almond
Truthly × Knights
Beauty
Medium roast
55
Agtron
Milk chocolate · Roasted almond · Honey · Smooth caramel
Patience
Decaf · medium
50
Agtron
Milk chocolate · Caramel · Graham cracker
Faith
Dark roast
45
Agtron
Brown sugar · Molasses · Buttery body
Truthly × Knights
Truth
Dark roast
40
Agtron
Dark chocolate · Molasses · Toasted cacao
Fortitude
Dark roast
35
Agtron
Dark cocoa · Smoky cedar · Bittersweet
Justice
French roast
30–35
Agtron
Toasted marshmallow · Molasses · Oak
The Cup Score
84 points. Four points above the line that matters.
Every coffee in the world can be scored out of 100 by certified graders — aroma, flavor, acidity, body, balance, sweetness. 80 is the line. Score 80 or higher with zero primary defects and it's specialty coffee. Score under it and it's commodity — whatever the label says. Our coffees cup at 84.
Where big-brand coffee lives: the whole gray stretch under 80. Commodity coffee is bought on price, not points — most of it is never cup-scored at all.
Why specialty costs more
What the extra points are paying for
Graded, not guessed
Certified Q Graders cup every lot across ten attributes before it earns a score. Under 80 doesn't make the cut — literally. There's no marketing word for it because it isn't specialty.
Zero primary defects
Specialty grade allows no moldy, sour, or insect-damaged beans in the grading sample. What's in the cup is the coffee itself — nothing has to be hidden or burned off.
Picked ripe, paid right
Specialty lots are picked at peak ripeness and bought for quality at above-commodity prices — traceable to real farms and real farmers, then roasted in small batches and shipped fresh.
The big-brand reality
Why the cheap bag is cheap
Bought like corn
Commodity coffee trades on an exchange by the ton, like corn or oil. The cheapest lot wins the contract. The score isn't part of the deal — it isn't even measured.
Defects by the handful
Commodity grading permits defective beans in every lot — unripe, fermented, insect-damaged. Roast it dark enough and every coffee tastes the same: burnt. That's not a style. It's a cover-up.
Old before you buy it
Roasted months ahead, warehoused, shipped, and shelved. By the time it brews, whatever flavor it once had is gone — what's left is bitter, flat, and stale.
Scores per the Specialty Coffee Association's 100-point cupping scale.
Specialty grade: 80+ points with zero primary defects. Bag prices are typical US retail ranges for a 12 oz bag in each band.